Why does your current putter feel like a jittery liability on short, breaking putts? Transitioning to a longer shaft can settle your nerves and simplify your stroke.
Finding the Best Broomstick Putters requires sorting through different lengths and head shapes to suit your posture. These tools provide the stability you need to roll the ball with confidence. Read on to see which models might help your game.
Key Takeaways
- Prioritize a length that allows your eyes to sit directly over the ball without forcing a hunched posture.
- Select a head weight that balances against the longer shaft to provide consistent feedback through your stroke.
- Ensure the grip configuration allows for a split-hand hold to prevent the lead wrist from breaking down at impact.
- Check the face milling or insert material to match your preferred level of firmness at impact.
- Consider a mallet head shape if you struggle with off-center strikes and need extra forgiveness.
| The Gold Standard |  |
TaylorMade Spider Broomstick Putter | High stability mallet head | Extremely consistent roll | Clean alignment markers | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Tall Player Preference | Cleveland Huntington Beach 48-Inch Putter | Perfect for upright stance | Soft milled face | Predictable distance control | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Mid-Length Stability | Cleveland Huntington Beach 46-Inch Putter | Manageable shaft length | Soft responsive feel | Easy to frame alignment | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Alignment Master |  |
Odyssey Square to Square Putter | Promotes square face | Straight stroke assistance | Unique visual cues | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Southpaw Long-Game Solution |  |
Bell III Left Hand Putter | Left-handed design | Face-on stroke compatible | Polished durable finish | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Essential Comfort Upgrade |  |
Winn Excel Two-Piece Grip | Superior tacky feel | Two-piece construction | Excellent feedback | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Perimeter Weighting King |  |
TaylorMade Spider X Putter | Exceptional perimeter weighting | Streamlined mallet shape | Crisp impact feedback | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Modern Mallet Versatility |  |
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 11 | Speed-optimized face milling | Forgiving mallet design | Versatile performance | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Classic Mallet Feel | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8 | Soft rounded head | Excellent roll consistency | Easy alignment | View on Amazon | Read Review | |
| Best Value Mallet | Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter | Anti-glare finish | Generous sweet spot | Counterbalanced performance | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
TaylorMade Spider Broomstick Putter
If you want the stability of a high-MOI mallet paired with the modern broomstick length, this is the benchmark. The weight distribution helps keep the putter head moving on a consistent path, which is exactly what you need when you are nursing those tricky five-footers.
It feels remarkably balanced through the stroke. Because the Spider head design is so iconic, you get a clean look at address that simplifies your alignment. Just keep in mind that the large head profile might feel a bit clunky if you prefer a traditional blade aesthetic.
- Brand Name:TaylorMade
- Head Style:Mallet
- Shaft Length:48 inches
- Putter Model:Spider
- Additional Feature:High MOI head design
- Additional Feature:Proven mallet geometry
- Additional Feature:Consistent weight distribution
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach 48-Inch Putter
This model is built for the golfer who needs extra length to stand tall over the ball. The 48-inch shaft allows you to maintain an upright posture, which often helps in taking the wrists out of the stroke entirely.
You will notice the milled face pattern, which is designed to soften the feel at impact. It is a solid choice if you struggle with distance control because the face provides a very predictable energy transfer. Be aware that the longer shaft requires a bit of practice to manage the swing weight effectively.
- Brand Name:Cleveland Golf
- Head Style:Mallet
- Shaft Length:48 inches
- Putter Model:HB Soft 2 #11
- Additional Feature:Speed optimized face milling
- Additional Feature:Upright posture assistance
- Additional Feature:Classic mallet shape
-
Cleveland Huntington Beach 46-Inch Putter
If the 48-inch options feel slightly too long, this 46-inch version provides a more manageable leverage point. It keeps the same HB Soft face milling found in the longer models, so you do not sacrifice feel for the sake of a specific shaft length.
The head is a modern mallet shape that frames the ball beautifully. It helps those who fight a shaky stroke by adding a bit of weight and balance. Just make sure you measure your ideal anchor point, as two inches makes a noticeable difference in your setup.
- Brand Name:Cleveland Golf
- Head Style:Mallet
- Shaft Length:46 inches
- Putter Model:HB Soft 2 #11
- Additional Feature:Milled face pattern
- Additional Feature:Modern mallet head
- Additional Feature:Balanced weight distribution
-
Odyssey Square to Square Putter
Odyssey took a different approach here, focusing on the geometry of the stroke. This putter is designed to help you keep the face square throughout the motion, acting like a mechanical guide for your hands.
It is ideal for golfers who tend to manipulate the face at impact. The distinctive shape encourages a straight-back and straight-through path. It might look a little unusual in your bag, but the results on the green often justify the aesthetic departure.
- Brand Name:Odyssey
- Head Style:Mallet
- Putter Model:Square to Square
- Additional Feature:Face balancing technology
- Additional Feature:Alignment-focused geometry
- Additional Feature:Consistent path design
-
Bell III Left Hand Putter
Finding a left-handed broomstick putter is like finding a hidden gem in a dusty shop, but this model delivers exactly what you need. It features a face-on design that works well for those who prefer to face the target rather than the ball.
The mallet head provides enough mass to keep the putter tracking straight. It is a specialized tool, so it is best suited for golfers who have already committed to the broomstick style. The polished finish is a nice touch that holds up well over time.
- Brand Name:Bell III
- Head Style:Mallet
- Hand Orientation:Left
- Additional Feature:No-anchor design
- Additional Feature:Face-on putting style
- Additional Feature:Sturdy mallet construction
-
Winn Excel Two-Piece Grip
Sometimes the putter head is fine, but the grip is holding you back. This two-piece system allows you to customize the placement for a broomstick setup, which is crucial for comfort and control.
Winn is known for their tacky material, which stays secure even in humid weather. If you are building a custom long putter, starting with this grip will give you the right level of feedback. Just remember that installing two-piece grips requires a bit of patience to get the alignment perfect.
- Brand Name:Winn
- Grip Type:Two-piece
- Additional Feature:Moisture resistant material
- Additional Feature:Comfortable feel
- Additional Feature:Custom configuration ready
-
TaylorMade Spider X Putter
The Spider X is all about perimeter weighting, which helps minimize twisting on off-center hits. It is a fantastic choice if your stroke is slightly inconsistent, as the high MOI acts like a shock absorber for your errors.
The shape is a bit more refined than previous versions, offering a streamlined look that many golfers find easier to focus on. It provides a crisp feel that lets you know exactly where you caught the ball on the face. If you like a slightly firmer impact, this is your best bet.
- Brand Name:TaylorMade
- Head Style:Mallet
- Putter Model:Spider X
- Additional Feature:High MOI construction
- Additional Feature:Refined head profile
- Additional Feature:Weight-forward stability
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 11
If you want the technology of the HB Soft 2 line in a standard-length package, Model 11 is a top contender. It uses the same speed-optimized milling as the broomstick versions, ensuring your ball rolls true every time.
The mallet head is large enough to be forgiving but compact enough to feel maneuverable. It is a versatile performer that suits a wide range of stroke types. Don't let the simplicity fool you; it does the heavy lifting on the green so you don't have to.
- Brand Name:Cleveland Golf
- Head Style:Mallet
- Putter Model:HB Soft 2 Model 11
- Additional Feature:Consistent ball roll
- Additional Feature:Forgiving head shape
- Additional Feature:Premium milling finish
-
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 8
Model 8 offers a slightly different take on the mallet aesthetic compared to the 11. It features a rounded profile that is great for golfers who prefer a softer look at address rather than sharp lines.
The face milling remains the star of the show, providing a consistent roll regardless of how well you strike the center of the face. It is a reliable partner for those who struggle with distance control. You will appreciate how easily it squares up at impact.
- Brand Name:Cleveland Golf
- Head Style:Mallet
- Putter Model:HB Soft 2 Model 8
- Additional Feature:Milled face pattern
- Additional Feature:Rounded mallet profile
- Additional Feature:Balanced construction
-
Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter
Wilson has put together a highly effective mallet that doesn't overcomplicate things. The Bucktown features a dark, anti-glare finish that keeps your eyes focused on the line rather than the sun reflecting off your club.
It feels solid and provides a generous sweet spot, which is a huge benefit if you are trying to simplify your game. The counterbalance technology helps keep the head moving smoothly throughout the stroke. It is a straightforward tool that gets the job done without any unnecessary flair.
- Brand Name:Wilson
- Head Style:Mallet
- Putter Model:Bucktown
- Additional Feature:Counterbalance technology
- Additional Feature:Dark non-reflective finish
- Additional Feature:Solid impact feel
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a broomstick putter help me stop yipping?
Many golfers switch to this style specifically to eliminate the involuntary twitching associated with the yips. By anchoring the club against your chest, you remove the small, shaky muscles in your hands and wrists from the equation. It forces your large shoulder muscles to power the stroke instead.
Is it difficult to adjust to the long shaft?
It takes a few sessions to find your rhythm, but the pendulum motion is surprisingly intuitive. You are essentially turning your arms into a swinging gate that moves back and forth in a straight line. Focus on keeping your top hand steady while your shoulders drive the movement.
Can I use any putter grip on these clubs?
You should stick to grips specifically designed for long putters, as they are longer and often come in two separate pieces. Using a standard grip will make it nearly impossible to maintain the correct hand separation required for the broomstick technique. Specialized grips are built to handle the unique leverage of a 45-inch shaft.
Are these putters allowed in official tournaments?
You can use them, but the rules strictly forbid anchoring the club directly against your body. You must hold the top of the grip a slight distance away from your sternum while you putt. As long as you maintain that small gap, you stay within the legal framework of the game.
How do I transport such a long club?
These putters are definitely awkward to carry, as they often poke out of the top of a standard golf bag. You might need to remove your driver or fairway woods to make room for the longer shaft during transit. Consider using a hard-shell travel case if you are flying, as the extra length makes the club more prone to bending or snapping.
